Searching for Answers to Causes of Childhood Depression
Searching for Answers to Causes of Childhood Depression
Over the past decade, scientists have produced a flurry of studies exploring the role of genetic (nature) and environmental factors (nurture) in youth depression, but there has been little consensus on how depression is jointly impacted by specific genes and external factors, such as poverty, abuse, and negative family relationships.
The lack of a clear understanding of how genes and environments both contribute to childhood depression led Erin Dunn, postdoctoral research fellow and recent graduate of the Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH), and her colleagues to do a comprehensive review of studies that tested for gene-environment interaction in youth depression. Their goal was to systematically identify these studies, examine the methods used, and summarize findings to guide future studies. The review was published December, 2011 in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry (JCPP). Read the abstract.
Dunn, a former Richmond Fellow at the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University, has had a longstanding interest in children’s mental health ever since teaching in early childhood and elementary school settings, where she saw students with a variety of mental health issues.
Journey to discovery
“When the Human Genome Project began we thought we were going to find all the genetic determinants of mental illness and other health problems we face. The journey to discover all those genes has been much more complicated than originally envisioned,” said Dunn, who is now a post-doctoral research fellow in the Psychiatric and Neurodevelopmental Genetics Unit in the Center for Human Genetic Research at Massachusetts General Hospital.
The Connecticut native led a study team that included HSPH researchers S V Subramanian, professor of population health and geography, Jordan Smoller, associate professor in epidemiology, and senior author Karestan Koenen, adjunct associate professor of society, human development, and health.
According to the National Institute of Mental Health, about 11% of adolescents have a depressive disorder by age 18. Girls are more likely than boys to experience depression. The risk for depression increases as a child gets older. The World Health Organization considers major depressive disorder the leading cause of disability among Americans age 15 to 44. Studies in twins show that between 30-80% of the variation in youth-onset depression is due to genes. Other contributors are environmental factors such as poverty, family relationships, divorce, or abuse.
“Getting depression early in life is particularly bad because depression tends to recur and can lead to a poor quality of life and poor social and work outcomes,” Dunn said. What intrigues her is that not all youth exposed to these environmental risk factors develop depression, raising questions about individual differences in genetic sensitivity to adverse environmental conditions.
A bird’s-eye view
To conduct the latest study, Dunn and her colleagues searched two major scientific literature databases of studies published between 2003 and March 2010. Of 278 articles on the subject, they identified 20 studies that tested for candidate gene-environment interaction in youth (up to age 26). In those, the researchers compared research design, samples studied, measures used, genes explored, and environmental factors studied.
While 16 of the 20 studies identified both genetic and environmental factors as increasing the risk of depression, the studies employed such a mix of methods, analyses, and measures that it was challenging to compare findings and assess “the strength of the evidence” for specific gene-environment interactions.
“Our study provides a bird’s-eye view of gaps in this field revealed in this literature review,” Dunn said. “We need to pump the brakes a bit and do a better job of doing more rigorous science,” she said. “The public health implication is that we can’t think solely in terms of genetics and environment—we have to think of both. The challenge for the field is to figure out the best strategies to do that.”
The researchers included 20 recommendations in the paper to guide future studies. Their guidelines include how to conceptualize, measure, analyze, and report genetic-environment interactions. “We wanted to develop a set of recommendations to move this exciting and powerful field forward,” Dunn said.
Funding for the study was provided by the Richmond Fellowship from the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard and the National Institute of Mental Health.
“Research Review: Gene-Environment Interaction Research in Youth Depression – A Systematic Review with Recommendations for Future Research,” Erin C. Dunn, Monica Uddin, S.V. Subramanian, Jordan W. Smoller, Sandro Galea, and Karestan C. Koenen. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, December 2011.
By Marge Dwyer
Harvard School of Public Health
photo: Aubrey LaMedica
About Harvard Medical School (HMS)
Driving Change. Building Momentum. Making History.
“Since 1872, Harvard Medical School has been the incubator of bold ideas—a place where extraordinary people advance education, science and health care with unrelenting passion.
Whether training tomorrow’s doctors and scientists, decoding the fundamental nature of life, advancing patient care or improving health delivery systems around the world, we are never at rest. Allied with some of the world’s best hospitals, research institutes and a University synonymous with excellence, the School’s mission remains as ambitious as it is honorable: to alleviate human suffering caused by disease.”
About Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH)
Harvard School of Public Health is dedicated to advancing the public’s health through learning, discovery and communication. More than 400 faculty members are engaged in teaching and training the 1,000-plus student body in a broad spectrum of disciplines crucial to the health and well being of individuals and populations around the world. Programs and projects range from the molecular biology of AIDS vaccines to the epidemiology of cancer; from risk analysis to violence prevention; from maternal and children’s health to quality of care measurement; from health care management to international health and human rights.
About Harvard University.
Established in 1636, Harvard is the oldest institution of higher education in the United States. The University, which is based in Cambridge and Boston, Massachusetts, has an enrollment of over 20,000 degree candidates, including undergraduate, graduate, and professional students. Harvard has more than 360,000 alumni around the world.
Harvard University is devoted to excellence in teaching, learning, and research, and to developing leaders in many disciplines who make a difference globally. Harvard faculty are engaged with teaching and research to push the boundaries of human knowledge. For students who are excited to investigate the biggest issues of the 21st century, Harvard offers an unparalleled student experience and a generous financial aid program, with over $160 million awarded to more than 60% of our undergraduate students. The University has twelve degree-granting Schools in addition to the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, offering a truly global education.
‘Universities nurture the hopes of the world: in solving challenges that cross borders; in unlocking and harnessing new knowledge; in building cultural and political understanding; and in modeling environments that promote dialogue and debate… The ideal and breadth of liberal education that embraces the humanities and arts as well as the social and natural sciences is at the core of Harvard’s philosophy. ’/ Drew Gilpin Faust
* The above story is adapted from materials provided by Harvard University